|
LORD MAGINNIS OF DRUMGLASS’
ADDRESS TO THE HOUSE OF LORDS, ON 20 NOVEMBER 2006.
My Lords, I am grateful for the
opportunity to speak about the Turkish Republic of
Northern Cyprus in this debate. I last addressed
this House on the Cyprus issue in July 2005. Since
then, our Government have done virtually nothing
other than rehearse their good intentions-meaninglessly
and without achievement. While one cannot force an
agreement if either of the two traditions in Cyprus
is unwilling, there are things that the United
Kingdom Government could and should do. They can
take action on matters within their own competence
and influence the policy of other nations within the
European Union and the United Nations. In April
2004, the Annan plan for a Cyprus settlement was
endorsed by virtually the whole world as a fair and
reasonable compromise. Despite the fact that it
contained considerable risks for them, the Turkish
Cypriots accepted it. The Greek Cypriots rejected
it. They were entitled to reject it but-and this is
the crucial point-having rejected it, they should no
longer expect the world to assist them to keep the
Turkish Cypriots in isolation. I shall address some
of the practical effects of this isolation. It
denies Turkish Cypriots the right of representation
in almost every international forum. It prevents or
restricts the use of ports and airports in Northern
Cyprus. It precludes Turkish Cypriots having access
to financial markets, curtails trade and tourism,
and hampers all cultural and sporting relations
between the TRNC and other countries. Turkish
Cypriots have done nothing to deserve this treatment,
nor has it ever been authorised by a sanctions
resolution under Chapter 7 of the United Nations
Charter. Neither did this situation emanate simply
from the 2004 Annan plan referendum. Turkish
Cypriots have been under isolation from as long ago
as 1963, when the Greek Cypriots massacred hundreds
of their men, women and children and drove them into
defensive enclaves. The Turkish defence of these
people in 1974 was necessary and justifiable. In his
memoirs, Sir Alec Douglas-Home wrote: "I was early
convinced that if [the Greek Cypriot leader] could
not bring himself to treat the Turkish Cypriots as
human beings, he was inviting the invasion and
partition of the island". Perhaps I may remind your
Lordships what world leaders have said about the
isolation of the Turkish Cypriots after they
accepted the Annan plan. On26 April 2004, the
European Council said in a statement: "The Turkish
Cypriot community have expressed their clear desire
for a future within the European Union. The Council
is determined to put an end to the isolation of the
Turkish Cypriot community and to facilitate the
reunification of Cyprus by encouraging the economic
development of the Turkish Cypriot community". A
foreign affairs committee report in another place,
dated 1 February 2005, said that, "undertakings
given to Turkish Cypriots by the international
community must be honoured. We recommend that the
Government do more to turn its words into action".
One particularly urgent matter is the denial of
direct flights to Turkish Cypriot airports. This
means that all flights to Ercan have to stop over at
a Turkish airport, adding considerably to time, cost
and inconvenience, and putting Northern Cyprus at a
major competitive disadvantage. On 18 May 2004,
Prime Minister Blair had this to say: "I think it is
important...that we end the isolation of northern
Cyprus... that means lifting the embargoes in
respect of trade, in respect of air travel". Again,
the Foreign Office Minister told this House that, "the
British Government fully, support the agreed EU
policy of ending the isolation of Turkish Cypriots.
Direct flights to Northern Cyprus could play a
useful role in bringing that about".-[Official
Report, 8/7/04; col. 916.] Yet, when I asked the
Foreign Office Minister on1 February 2005 when
direct flights were going to commence, I was told
that the Government were considering the legal
issues. I accept that the legal issues may be
complex, but even the slowest lawyers would have
come to a conclusion by now. The Government have not
produced any legal argument as to why direct flights
should not be permitted. I therefore conclude that
none exists, a conclusion I have had confirmed by
two eminent British legal counsel. I understand it
is a matter within the United Kingdom Government's
own competence, not a matter for the EU. Therefore,
direct flights could commence without further delay.
Thereafter, I would also expect our Government to
encourage other Governments, within and outside the
EU, to follow suit. Turkish Cypriots earned the
right to be relieved of their isolation when they
voted for the Annan plan. As the United Nations
Secretary-General said at the time:
"The Turkish Cypriot vote has
undone any rationale for pressuring and isolating
them".
If time had permitted, I would
have sought to address the property issue, which is
one of the most contentious. Suffice that I should
draw attention to the Orams case, where the English
judge intimated that property issues in Cyprus are
international issues which cannot be settled in the
courts. I trust that his judgment will be upheld on
appeal. The Turkish Cypriot government have now,
unilaterally, established a claims commission, and
Greek Cypriots, despite official disapproval and
hindrance by the Greek Cypriot Government, are
already applying for reinstatement or compensation.
When considering the property issue, however, we
must never forget that there is a quid pro quo-those
thousands of Turkish Cypriots who lost properties in
the south that are now occupied by Greek Cypriots.
In conclusion, I challenge the Government to say
whether this farce has not gone on long enough. Are
a quarter of a million Turkish Cypriots, living at
peace with their neighbours, not as important in
human rights terms as Iraqis, Afghans or ourselves?
Let us have an end of hypocrisy and mere lip service
and ensure that Turkish Cypriots at long last
achieve their rightful place in a democratic Europe.
(Lord Maginnis speech to House of Lords (on Monday
20 November 2006) |